• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Recipes
  • Easy Ideas

Homemade in Astoria logo

  • HOME
  • SHOPPING GUIDE
  • LOCAL FAVES
  • BALCONY GARDENING
  • ABOUT & CONTACT

December 15, 2019 Cooking Tips

10 Chocolate Chip Cookie Tips

Chocolate chip cookies

Through much trial and error from the age of 8, I have developed my own set of chocolate chip cookie tips. In about 1984, my oldest sister burned a batch of Nestle Tollhouse cookies and I whined so much that I was actually crying. Even after that traumatic incident, she made them countless times and they were always horrible. From then on, I was determined to make them just the way they appeared in pictures.  

Me with my oldest sister who gave me the initial motivation to make  cookies the right way … because she definitely could not! This pic was taken around the time when it all started, circa 1984.

Of course, these chocolate chip cookie tips can be applied to some other types of cookies. But these are my babies. In college when I worked in a gourmet deli, we had a really mean, hard-to-please boss out of culinary school. The day I brought in a batch of my cookies for the crew, I earned a few brownie points with her. I saw her approaching out of the corner of my eye and thought I was in trouble. Instead, I was showered with praise about the perfect texture of my cookies.

It was at this job in a gourmet deli in in Minneapolis where I first received praise from a professional chef about my Chocolate Chunk Cookies, circa 1998.

Another crucial influence in my cookie culinary history comes from my mom. For 13 years she was a Girl Scout leader and I tagged along on all of the troop’s activities. As a fundraiser, they sold cookbooks full of recipes submitted by all the girls and my mom included a recipe from me … Chocolate Chip Squares or Bars. This was technically my first published recipe at the age of 8. I had no idea I would one day have a cooking blog, and it just so happens that my first recipe on my blog was Bittersweet Chocolate Chunk Cookies. My instructions were getting so complicated that  chocolate chip cookie tips need their own page.

My first chocolate chip cookie recipe

Having my mom include me in her Girl Scout troop’s cookbook was my first published recipe at the age of 8 … for Chocolate Chip Squares or Bars.

So … below is my long list of dos and don’ts. Not having gone to culinary school, I can truly say I learned everything the hard way.  Many decades of my failures and successes will save you time and money when you make your next batch.

1. Cut your own chocolate chunks.

Making your own chocolate chunks gives your cookies more character. Also, you have the flexibility to combine different types of chocolate. Most mainstream chocolate chips are semisweet, but consider trying bittersweet or even milk chocolate. Callebaut is the brand that I love. Simply use the tip of a sharp knife to chisel away pieces from a chunk of baking chocolate. Do this first.

Use a small knife that you don’t care too much about and use your palm as a mallet. It takes a while, but well worth it. You don’t want any small shavings because they will melt off in the dough. Hand pick each chocolate chunk and set them aside. Save the shavings for something else like ice cream toppings. 

bittersweet baking chocolate for my chocolate chip cookie recipe

homemade chocolate chunks for chocolate chip cookie

2. Butter temperature is crucial.

If the butter is too warm and soft, your cookies will be wide and flat. Cooler butter will yield more height, such as the case with making scones where the butter is really cold. My recipe uses half shortening and half butter because I praise the texture shortening provides. If you’re not into using shortening, just use it as a point of reference for your butter temperature and consistency. To quickly heat up your butter you can cover it in saran wrap and pound it with a rolling pin a few times, see below.

butter and shortening warmed for chocolate chip cookies

European butter being pounded

Pounding cold butter with a rolling pin speeds up the butter-warming process.

3. Mix everything by hand and don’t over-mix.

Roll up your sleeves, wash your hands and really get in there. If you’re not crazy about using your hands, use a fork. Or, I find a pastry blender is extremely effective (see below). Mix everything just until ingredients are incorporated. Most importantly … don’t use an electric mixer.

pastry blender

Feel free to use a pastry blender to cream your butter if you’re not into using your hands.

4. Don’t use old baking soda. 

Baking soda expires 30 days after you open it. Not only does it lose its effectiveness in helping to obtain a nice rise, but it also absorbs odors. You definitely don’t want absorbed odors tainting your cookies. If you don’t bake often and you have baking soda just laying around in your cupboard, chances are that it’s expired. So, definitely buy a new box.  

Baking soda expiration date

5. Eggs need to be at room temperature.

Baking with cold eggs is a universal rule to all recipes, so here it’s no different. Take your eggs out of the refrigerator a few hours ahead of time. Placing them in luke-warm water can help speed up this process.

6. Use large eggs.

Bigger is not better in this case, so don’t try using extra large or jumbo eggs. Too much egg will make your chocolate chip cookies cake-like. When a recipe says to use large eggs, they really mean it. Large eggs are actually the unwritten standard in baking.

7. Do not roll the dough into balls. 

Sure you can do this if you really want to, but you won’t achieve a nice texture with peaks and valleys on its surface. Also, the less you handle the dough, the better – which ties in with Tip #3 on not over-mixing.

chocolate chip cookie dough

8. Do not save the dough to bake later.

This is one of my chocolate chip cookie tips that I learned in high school. Saving the dough never works out well because the baking soda has a window of time to be effective for a good rise. My recipe actually yields the amount for a double batch, and you just have to push through if you’re losing steam. Use it all up!

chocolate chip cookies cooling

Using up all of the cookie dough often means baking batches into some late hours of the evening. These were still happening at 11:45 PM.

9. Factor in cooling time.

Many people love a hot, gooey chocolate chip cookie with molten chocolate fresh out of the oven. However, during this cooling time, your cookies are still technically baking on the pan. Remove them from the oven as soon as they start to turn a little golden. It’s okay if they seem a little under-done. Unless you’re in a situation where you may have over-baked them, leave the cookies alone for at least 10 minutes. Go do something else and forget about them completely. Put the entire sheet on a wire rack so the heat can release from the bottom as well as the top. After the 20 minutes your cookies should be just firm enough to transfer onto the wire racks individually without falling through the grates. 

chocolate chip cookies fresh out of the oven

10. Use pure vanilla extract. 

The world of vanilla extract is quite vast and I’m not exactly sure why imitation vanilla extract even exists … or what it consists of. You can spend lots of money on a really good brand – such as Nielsen Massey – but McCormick offers pure vanilla extract at almost every mainstream supermarket in the $6–$10 price range.

Well, that’s really all you need to know. Good luck!

My freshly baked chocolate chip cookie

Categories: Cooking Tips Tags: baking tips, chocolate chip cookie tips

Stay in touch with me on Instagram in between posts!

Join my list!

Receive instant notifications on new posts, reviews, and recipe updates.

Previous Post: « Sofrito of the American South
Next Post: Some Tips on Baked Kale Chips »

Primary Sidebar

I’m a lover of cross-cultural comfort food and I spend my weekends cooking authentically awesome dishes without having to leave Astoria, Queens, NYC.

-Ben Costantino

BROWSE ALL PREVIOUS POSTS

  • Chicken (6)
  • Cocktails and Beverages (4)
  • Cooking Tips (6)
  • Desserts (5)
  • Easy Ideas (18)
  • Ingredients (19)
  • Meatless (39)
  • Recipes (55)

Meatless Monday Ideas!

broiled buffalo cauliflower

Broiled Buffalo Cauliflower

Kale slaw with Sriracha mayo dressing

Sriracha Kale Slaw

Burnt Ends Fried Plantains Smothered in Barbecue Sauce

Braised Potatoes in Puerto Rican Sofrito Sauce

Sweet Potato Vegan Chili with fresh avocado

Chipotle Vegan Chili with Sweet Potatoes

baked kale chips

Some Tips on Baked Kale Chips

Buffalo Roasted Chickpeas

Sautéed Cabbage with Jamaican Curry

Check out more Meatless Monday inspired posts!

Visit me on Instagram in between posts!

  • Instagram
How does one know when to stop when ur caramelizin How does one know when to stop when ur caramelizing onions? Thought I was done about 4 times.  Was feeling patient yesterday and wanted them on a sandwich, but once I was done I just grabbed a fork and went all in on these. 

#caramelization #caramelizedonions #lownslowcooking #skilletcooking #onionlover  #classiccooking #cookingtechnique #homecookfood #cookingonions #onions #amateurcook #stovetopcooking #onionsrule
Channeling my inner Usain Bolt feeling @usainbolt Channeling my inner Usain Bolt feeling @usainbolt @usainbolt.fan after a good meatless-fueled cardio while my weight is at an all-time record low in my adult life. Even with a knee injury I found ways to thrive ... instead of really running I'm doing an "old man" type of run-walk maneuver with a knee brace because doing absolutely nothing while it heals is not an option in my book. 

 #fitness2020 #doingcardio #usainboltfan #outdoorfitness #stayinginshape #fitnessgoals #runlikethewind #astoriapark #queensnewyorkcity #astorianyc #blackfitnessmatters #livinginastoria #astorialife #quarantinefitness #losingweight #fitinmy40s #nycparks #healthyliving #cardioworkout #determination #foodandfitness
Swapping olive oil mayo with honey mustard led to Swapping olive oil mayo with honey mustard led to this 3 ingredients dressing of this spicy kale slaw with cashews ... Sriracha, honey mustard and rice vinegar. No fat happening here. 
.
.
#kaleslaw #kalestagram #3ingredients #nofatfood #srirachalovers #sriracharecipes #spicyfood #spicy #veggiepower #micronutrients #kaleaddict #kalepower #simplerecipe #easycooking #dietfoods #skinnyrecipes #cashews #eatyourveggies #colorfulcooking #freshveggies #eatinghealthy  #carrots🥕 #healthy #eatingclean
Nowadays, a whole wheat pita with jammy eggs, blan Nowadays, a whole wheat pita with jammy eggs, blanched kale, fresh spinach, quinoa, and roasted red peppers tossed in a little ranch dressing with swiss cheese appeals to me more than a bacon egg ‘n cheese breakfast sandwich. This certainly wasn’t always the case. The concept of dieting was so foreign to me because as an athlete all my life I always pretty much ate whatever I wanted until recent years and a slight tummy started emerging that I couldn’t get rid of. Meat was certainly the culprit, combined with having to increase my cardio.
.
.
.
.
#meatless #pitasandwich #wholewheat #wholewheatpita #eathinghealthy #dieting #healthylifestyle #eatingbetter #kaleandquinoa #eggsandwich #plantbasedsandwich #pocketpita #vegetarianeats #freshveggiesmatter #eatgoodfeelgood #youarewhatyoueat #dietgoals #lifestylechanges #nutrition #eggsarethebest #eggprotein #vegetariandiet #eggsandveggies #softboiledegg #jammyegg
Time to put my jammy egg skills to the test after Time to put my jammy egg skills to the test after watching the egg tutorial from @elle_simone_scott at @testkitchen on youtube. 
🥚
.
.
.
#jammyeggs #softboiledeggs #cookingeggs #eggaddict #iloveeggs #eggsellent #protein #eggcooking #simplefood #breakfastfood #runnyyolk #yolkporn #homecook #eggs101 #cookingtechniques #howtocook #eggvideo #imadethis #eggslover #homecookingblogger #comfortfood #simplecooking #learningtocook #softboiled #atkgrams
In case ya didn't know ... thyme and sage are toug In case ya didn't know ... thyme and sage are tough enough to withstand freezing temperatures. I had no idea. Now I'm wondering what other herbs can grow year round ... I'm guessing rosemary? Hopefully tarragon. Will see. I always hate when you buy herbs, use only what you need, and the rest lingers in the fridge for way too long and ya feel bad for wasting such a fantastic product. Not anymore. 🌱

#urbangardener #gardeninginpots #freshherbs  #sageplant #thyme #thymeandsage #growingherbs #herbgrower #herbs #igrewthis  #herbgardening #thymesfragrances #sagephotos #sagelove #plantphotography #herblover #growyourownherbs🌱 #frommygarden
My meatless journey has led me to yesterday's #tac My meatless journey has led me to yesterday's #tacotuesday🌮 with quinoa, cotija cheese, blanched broccoli, home-pickled Jalapeños, fried matchstick #julienned green plantains @elyucateco_hotsauce and @herdeztraditions guacamole salsa. The light feeling in your body the day after going meatless is super rewarding. I feel like I could run 10 miles 🏃🏼

#meatlesstacos #tacolovers #cleaneating #vegetariantacos #eatingfresh #vegetarianmexicanfood #tacosrule #homemadetacos #tacosathome #spicyfoodrecipes #pickledjalapeños #friedplantains🍌 #tacofixings #healthyeatinggoals #vegetariancooking #dietgoals #plantbasedmeal #tacolove #tacomaking #eatinglight #nomeattoday
Just a quick shallow fry in canola oil for these t Just a quick shallow fry in canola oil for these tostones takes the fear out of frying. Get with the search bar on the blog and type in "tostones" for the entire process. 

Haven't made these in quite a while ... I was long overdue. I first learned how to cook these from watching @chefdaisymartinez on #pbsfood in 2004. I used her cookbook so much that the pages are falling apart from the spine. They didn't have plantains in the small Rhode Island town where I grew up, and I first learned what a plantain was in college from a Nigerian friend circa 1998. The learning never stops.
.
.
.
#plátanosfritos #fryingplantains #shallowfry #friedfoodporn #snacks #snacktime #comidaboricua #comidalatina #fryingathome #fryingfood #platanosverdes #tostonesdeplatano #friedfoodheaven #frying #caribbeancooking #puertoricanfood #homecooklife #homecooksofinstagram #homecookedfood #nycfoodblog #nycbloggers
It's official chili season everyone ... holla 🙌 It's official chili season everyone ... holla 🙌🏾🙌🏻🙌🏿🙌🏼 if you like a little homemade chili 🌶️ with your #tostones.

#plantainlove #platanosfritos
#platanos #bowlofchili #friedplantain #chiliwithbeans #greenplantain #caribbeanfood #caribbeancooking #chiliseason #comidalatina #comfortcooking #friedfoods #blackfoodblogger #redchili #homemadechili #plantainpower #wintercooking
Reminiscing and mourning the memory of these Jamai Reminiscing and mourning the memory of these Jamaican jerk #chickenwings ... all of which only lasted 30 minutes on Saturday night. We quickly devoured these slow cooked beauties after a 24-hour marinade. 🍗
#ifeellikechickentonight
#chickennight #wingsintheoven #foodphotography #chickenwingchickenwing #wingnight #lownslowcooking #ovencooking #sheetpancooking #instachicken #chickengram #drummettes #drummetsofinstagram #chickenwingnight #chickenwingslovers #eatthis #wingaddict #spicyfoodlover #jamaicanchoicejerkseasoning #spicychicken #jamaicanchicken #yum
It's a personal rule that I don't allow collard gr It's a personal rule that I don't allow collard greens to linger for more than 2 days. After that I just can't deal. Poached eggs with greens and blacked peas is kinda my thing. Hot sauce @crystal.hot.sauce, egg yolk and the hearty broth I simmered up for hours all come together in this soulful bowl.

🥬

#poachedeggperfection #collardgreens #greensnbeans #blackeyedpeas #soulfood #soulinabowl #comfortfood #comfortcooking #bowlmeals #beansandgreens #collards #cozyfood #easyideas #blackhomecooks #blackfoodblogger #newyearsfood #goodluckfood #lickyourphone #egglover #poachingeggs
So, about last night. Um... I think these are done So, about last night. Um... I think these are done. Devoured these Jerk BBQ wings last night after a full day marinade with @jamaican_choice jerk seasoning. Low 'n slow is the way to go! 
🇯🇲
🍗
😋
.
.
.
.
#chickenwings #jerkchicken #jerkchickenwings
#jerkedchicken #foodiesofinstagram #cookingchicken #freshoutoftheoven #chickenaddiction #wings #wingsintheoven #ovenbaked #ovenlovin #chickenwaaangs #chickenlover #winglovers #fallingoffthebone #yummy #chicken #wingnight #cookedtoperfection #lownslow #ilovecooking  #homemadefood #everyoneloveschicken
Was given collard green duty by my bf @brothashake Was given collard green duty by my bf @brothashakespeare because ya can't just have blackeyed peas alone. No ham hock and no smoked turkey happening here. Instead I usually use a smoked pork chop for something I call "lean greens".

Well, there was no smoked pork chops at the store so I made a kick ass stock yesterday with regular pork chops, liquid smoke, and adding tons of onions, garlic and some other key secret ingredients. Complete Lean Greens recipe will be up on the blog soon. Until then ... Happy New Year 🎉🥂🥂🥂🥂🥂🥬🥬🥬🥬🥬
.
.
.
#collardgreens #collardgreenrecipes #soulfoodie #healthyishcooking #kindahealthy #cookinglight #greens #soulfoodcook #neosoulfood #greenfoodisgoodfood #leafygreens #collards #f52grams #cookingreens #homecookin #foodwithsoul #newyearsfood #eatmoregreens #comfortfood #stovetopcooking
We're getting these blackeyed peas on point so we We're getting these blackeyed peas on point so we can devour these at midnight. My bf @brothashakespeare doing a vegan version  this year and I'm super impressed how much I don't miss the meat. Looking forward to an awesome new year with even less meat in my diet. My goal in 2020 has been to only do meat once a day but I cheat often. No cheating in 2021, hopefully.
.
.
.
#blackeyedpeas #soulfood #soulfoodcooking #blackfoodies #africanamericanfood #blackeyedpeasforluck #homecooking #africanamericantraditions #beanrecipes #legumelover #vegansoulfood #neosoulfood #blackandproud #meatlesscooking #southerncooking #newyears2021 #hny2021 #comfortcooking #blacklivesmatter✊🏽✊🏾✊🏿 #blackhomecook #beans #cookingbeans #goodluck #optimism
The most simple and satisfying 3-ingredient recipe The most simple and satisfying 3-ingredient recipe (water and salt don’t count) of my year 2020 cooking adventures has been Tahini Dressing from @epicurious ... condiments and sauces are kinda my thing and if I don’t get enough of them I’m really not happy. Slathering this dressing on a whole wheat pita hummus sandwich will make you forget about eating meat altogether. It’s plays a crucial role in making my occasionally meatless diet such a success. 
💚🥙🥒🥬
.
.
.
.
.
#3ingredients #3ingredientrecipe #condiments #tahinidressing #dressingrecipe #hummusandpita #hummussandwich #hummusandveggies #wholewheatpita #roastedredpeppers #veggiesandwich #blanchedkale #grilledeggplant #grilledeggplant #meatlessgoals #meatlesseating #meatlessdiet #meatless #meatlesschallenge #plantbasednutrition #cleaneating #vegetarianmealprep #eatmoreveggies #tahinisauce #tahini #tahinilover #simplerecipes #easyrecipe #nutritous #nutritousanddelicious
I wish I could claim this #friedchicken, but it's I wish I could claim this #friedchicken, but it's what my boyfriend @brothashakespeare does every year as a Christmas tradition, being a southern man from Jackson, GA. I learn from the best and get it right on one of these days. 

#southernfriedchicken #fryingchicken #chickenloversforlife #deepfriedchicken #buttermilkfriedchicken #jacksongeorgia #chickenlovers🍗 #homecookin #friedfood #friedfoodporn #chickenaddict #everyoneloveschicken #chickenchickenchicken #deepfried #blackfoodiesmatter #chickenvideos #homemadefoodblogger #comfortfood #blackfoodbloggersclub #friedfoods
Making enchilada sauce is one of my favorite oh-so Making enchilada sauce is one of my favorite oh-so-satisfying things to do and usually happens in the late night hours. Full recipe is on the blog. Strained the hell out of this mixture of Ancho, Guajillo, Chipotle, and Arbol chilis 🌶️, and roasted tomatoes, onions and garlic.  Next step ... thin it out with some veggie stock and season it with Mexican oregano and cumin then simmer to completion. 
🌶️
Too many recipes tell you to remove the seeds, but I'm not about it. I want full heat. #spicyrecipe
🌶️
It's impossible to find meatless enchiladas to order in Astoria, so time to make my own ... any combo of black bean, veggie and cheese. And enchilada orders comes in threes and for some reason you can't order three different types like you can with tacos. Makes no sense. Now I can finally have one chicken and two meatless as much as I want.
.
.
.
.
#enchiladasauce #redsauce #mexicanfoodporn #enchiladalover #salsaroja #comidamexicana #saucemaking #mexicanchiles #guajillochile #anchochiles #redenchiladasauce #comfortcooking #spicysauce #spicyfoodlover🌶 #somelikeitspicy #enchiladalover #cookingfromscratch #freshingredients #mexicansauce #Mexicanflavors #mexicanfoodlover
I swear I had plans to just make a simple BLT, but I swear I had plans to just make a simple BLT, but these other awesome ingredients were calling from the fridge. So, here we go in order from bottom to the top ...honey mustard, @hellmannsmayonnaise olive oil mayonnaise, @yanceysfancycheese steakhouse onion cheddar, @smithfieldfoods bacon, vine tomatoes, @elyucateco_hotsauce red chili habañero hot sauce, cucumbers, shredded lettuce and @sabra Jalapeño hummus. 
🥪🥓🍅🥬🥒🧀🌶️

#sandwichmaker #sandwichtower #sandwich #sandwichpics #sandwichgram #sandwichlovers❤️ #hotsauceoneverything #oliveoilmayo #bltsandwich #baconsandwiches #baconlovers #sandwichs #sandwichoftheday #sandwichclub #sandwichtime #healthysandwich #healthyish #freshingredients #sandwichporn #homemadefood #lunchtime #sandwichmaking #sandwichphotography
Was out of mayo, so I reached for some blue cheese Was out of mayo, so I reached for some blue cheese dressing for this club sandwich with sweet potato coldcuts (on the blog), roasted red pepper, pickled Jalapeños, turkey, bacon, honey mustard and @elyucateco_hotsauce ... it might be a regular thing now. Blue cheese lover here!
🥪
All the sandwich lovers ... get with the search bar on my blog and type "sandwiches"

#bluecheesedressing #elyucatecohotsauce #sandwichaddict #sandwichesofinstagram #sandwichlover #sandwichloversunite #sandwichartist #sammich #makingasandwich #sandwichoftheday #roastedredpeppers #clubsandwich #sandwichesrule #sandwichporn #lunchfood #lunchtime #cookingathome #quarantinecooking #wishbonedressing #sandwichlife #sandwichmaker #homecooklife  #homecook
Winter workouts in full effect in #astoriaqueensny Winter workouts in full effect in #astoriaqueensny ... Astoria Park has become my second home since March and I'm so thankful to be living two blocks away from this fantastic park. When I'm not cooking, this is what I'm doing. Fun fact ... I was a gymnast from the age 6 to 21 and working out is just something I need to do. And just like cooking, fitness is in my DNA ... my bio-dad was a high school football superstar in the 70s in Rhode Island.

Haven't left Astoria in 9 months and it's all good in the hood. I've found ways to thrive in this pandemic.
💪🏻🤸🏻‍♂️🏃🏼
#nycparks #astoriany
#astoriaqueens #iloveastoria #quarentineworkout #outdoorfitness #outdoorworkout #nycbloggers #winterworkout #queensnewyorkcity #ilovequeens #fitness2020 #astoriapark #cardioworkouts #astoriaqueensnyc #stayinginshape #fitstagram #eatrightfeelright
Follow on Instagram

Most popular posts

Loading...

Help spread the word on Pinterest!

  • Pinterest

Join my list!

Receive instant notifications on new posts, reviews, and recipe updates.

food shopping in Astoria Queens

Shopping at my favorite store in Astoria, Queens on a hot summer day ... Trade Fair on 30th Avenue and 31st Street.

Check out my chicken recipes!

chicken salad
pulled chicken
chicken chili
Adobo Chicken

Copyright © 2021 Ben Costantino on the Cookd Pro Theme

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.